Here is the MI for Thomas Cain(e)

Braddan New Burial Ground
Section III
#4463
In loving memory of ELIZABETH CAIN beloved wife of THOMAS CAIN died 17th Jan 1919 aged 36 years
Also MARGARET CAIN beloved wife of the above died 18th April 1952 aged 53 years
Also THOMAS CAIN beloved husband of the above died 14th May 1957

Wife #1 was Mary--maybe Murphey
a Thomas Cain born 16 Oct 1880 Douglas to John Cain & Mary Murphey
That is the closest Thomas to your dates
Mary ? died after 1901

wife #2 was Elizabeth b 1883-1919

wife #3 was Margaret b 1899-1952

I think that Thomas' father was John James Cain b 1849/50 Andreas but not sure yet.
1851 Andreas Ballagawne
Ann 30 lb wife Peel, John James 1 Andreas

DJD