With reference to Frances' reply, this is the proposed connection I had in my files :

1804 Feb 1st, Malew, John, s. of John Callister and Elinor Cannel
1817 Aug 31 KK St Anne, William Callister s. of John Callister & Eleanor Cannell

(1841) Oatland, St Ann HO 107/1463/2 es16 p7 (ED2)
John Collister 37 Blacksmith IOM
Elizabeth “ 36 IOM
John Collister 11 IOM
Jane “ 9 IOM
Robert “ 7
Elizabeth “ 5 IOM
Catherine “ 3 IOM
Margaret “ 1
William Collister 24 Blacksm. Jy IOM [brother?]
James Kelly 19 Blacksm. Ap IOM
Rebecca Cannell 29 FS IOM
Elizabeth Moore 15 FS IOM

?William Callister m. Jane Bridson 27.5.1843 Braddan IGI
John s. of William Callister & Jane Bridson c.21.12.1845 Braddan IGI

?COLLISTER, Jane , 29 , bur. Bra , 8 Nov 1847 [mother of John?]

?William Callister mar. Margaret Hampton 10.11.1848 Santon IGI member sub

(1851) Kirk MichaelSt, Peel, German HO 107/2523 f.151 p.11 sch91
William Callister H m 34 Smith Santan
Margaret Callister w m 39? Braddan
John Callister s 5 scholar Braddan

?William Callister married Eleanor Hannah 21 Dec 1851 Braddan IGI

(1861) Fairclough Lane, West Derby, Liverpool RG9/2728 f.118 p.39 sch.39
William Collister H m 43 Blacksmith IOM
?Eleanor “ w m 32 IOM
John “ s 15 Farmer’s boy IOM
Elizabeth Shirwin lodger 44 servant Whitehaven

(1871) 1 South Quay, Douglas RG10/5776 f.146 p.19 sch 90
William Collister H m 52 Blacksmith Santon
Ellen “ w m 40 Rushen
Margaret Cooper adopted dau 15 scholar Douglas
Hannah C. French “ 10 “ Rushen

(1881) Ballacorkish, Rushen RG11/5608 f.24 sch.129
?Wm Collister H m 67 Railway gate keeper Santon
Elleanor “ w m 51 Rushen

(1881) Creggans Cottage No.1, Malew RG11/5607 f.93 p.16 sch.69
John Collister H m 35 Ag. Labourer Braddan
Sarah “ w m 34 Labourer’s wife Malew
Evalyn “ d 8 scholar “
John “ s 7 “ “
William “ s 4 “
Henry “ s 2mo “

John Collister m. Sarah Hudson 21.9.1871 Malew IGI

COLLISTER, Henry, 21 Jan 1881, Mal, COLLISTER, John & HUDSON, Sarah
COLLISTER, Edward, 5 Apr 1884, Arb, , COLLISTER, John & HUDSON, Sarah

COLLISTER, Sarah, 45, bur. San, 18 Dec 1890

(1891) Ballaglonney Cottage No.2, Malew RG12/4690 f.94 p.4 sch.22
John Collister H wid 45 Ag lab Braddan
Henry “ s s 10 scholar Malew
Edward “ s s 7 scholar Malew