Hi Frances,

I have no real doubts on it, Esther suits me, and I am sure it is correct, but as i said, I have been in touch with a descendant of the Casement family and the belief there from a transcript they have is Ellinor. I think it is probably a misreading, as the weight of evidence supports Esther, but I would check if I was on the island to set everyone's mind at rest.

I am sure you know the feeling, when you are 101% certain it has to be X, but you cant settle until you confirm that you were right !

Robert