JC....I also did the same exercise with Ann Kelly possibly Cain and did find an Ann Cain in the census. However, when I checked the children she was with I concluded that she was Ann Christian who married a Cain. So not much further ahead.

Yesterday I was googling and came upon a cached thread that was dated December 2004 of a family tree that suggests that my Ann Kelly did marry William Faragher but doesn't give any basis as to why the tree owner concluded this.

Mary Ann