Confusing group. Probably stick with Frances's choice as she has done extensive research in this area.

Earlier (14 Mar 2000) she said "I think one of your Redferns (George) was the Butcher in Duke St but there was also a Redfern Butcher whose shop was next to Redferns Hotel in James St run by Thomas (originally the Butchers Arms then Redferns) have alook at Douglas Inns under gazatteer section) makes likely location of Hotel that building sticking out into Market to
left and just above St Mathews . . ."