Family History Society

Hudgson/Hutchin - various spellings

Trying to find a needle in a haystack. A William Hudgen/Hutchin/Hudgson plus many other Welsh spellings - arrived in Wales, UK before the 1841 census. Born 'Isle of Man' to John about 1815. There are two candidates I have found so far - William Hutchin baptised 28 Mar 1812 Kirk Rushen son of John Hutchin and Margaret Clucas or William Hutchin baptised 30 Jun 1816 30 Jun 1816 Santon, son of John Hutchin and Jane Mylvorrey.
Hoping there is someone who can eliminiate one or both from my enquiries.